Stay Closed: A Tale of Two Tiny Board Game Boxes

I’m a fan of board games. I’m also a fan of good design. Naturally then, I’m a fan of well designed board game boxes. I’ve backed a few board game related Kickstarter projects in recent memory, and there are two that have particularly standout packaging – in both good and bad ways.

On one hand, we have Dungeon Roll with a shelf-unfriendly box but a perfect touch on a closing mechanism. And on the other hand, The Great Heartland Hauling Co. features a great travel-sized box that will probably dump its contents all over your bag if you attempt to travel with it. Read on for more!

Dungeon Roll

The Kickstarter campaign for Dungeon Roll (by Tasty Minstrel Games) was, to put it mildly, very successful. They raised a little over $250,000, surpassing their $15,000 goal fairly easily. It’s got custom dice and is in a dungeon, so I was powerless to avoid it. It also comes in an attractive treasure chest shaped box:

dungeon roll box

boxee-box-frontIt is attractive, but it’s really annoying to put on your shelf. And I need all the room I can on my shelf, of course. It reminds me of the original Boxee box and its “sinking cube” shape that demanded it was on the top of your entertainment stack. It looks good, sure, though it just makes life harder than it needs to be.

Good news though, the contents of your tiny treasure chest are secure – which is especially good, because there are quite a few tiny cardboard tokens that come with Dungeon Roll, and I would like to avoid losing. The box features a tiny magnet that helps keep the lid closed:

IMG_2022I love these kinds of touches! Plus, magnets!

So while it must live on top of my stack of games, it does travel well.

The Great Heartland Hauling Co.

The Great Heartland Hauling Co. (from Dice Hate Me Games) is also from Kickstarter, funded back in September 2012. As you might have guessed from the name, it’s literally a pickup and deliver game about big rigs hauling goods. And even further adding to the theme, the Kickstarter description even mentions the portability of the game so you can play the game on the road (I feel like Xzibit should be making an appearance anytime now…).

It’s true, the game does come in a very petite, portable-looking box:

the great heartland hauling co box

It’s small, it would definitely fit into a bag or some other portable-sized container. And it’s a relatively normal size, so it’s super easy to find a nook in the cabinet for it to live in harmony with all the other square boxes. But check out how full this box is with components:

IMG_2028

Considering the lack of depth in the box and how the lid doesn’t fit on super tight, this is a recipe for disaster. I know this for a fact because I’ve tried to travel with this game twice, and both times the box opened in transit and tiny cubes spilled out everywhere. Magnets would probably help this situation (as they generally do), but perhaps a slightly different/bigger shaped box would have been equally effective. Or, just a lid that fits tightly.

Conclusion

First thing, I feel compelled to say that I do enjoy both of these games. And, I appreciate that they don’t have artificially large boxes. Too many tiny games come in giant boxes so they can justify a higher price.

That said, having good packaging is an important part of the user experience of board games. Everybody that’s purchased an Apple product in recent memory knows the kind of care that goes into that packaging, and of course the “unboxing video” phenomenon that has come up in recent years.

Are there any board/card game boxes that you’ve found particularly good or bad? Epic tales of spilled components? Let’s discuss in the comments!

 

 

 

One thought on “Stay Closed: A Tale of Two Tiny Board Game Boxes

  1. The loose lid problem is pretty common with board games. I always use elastics to prevent boxes from opening during travel.

Leave a Reply